After her breakout in Obsession, fans want Inde Navarrette as the MCU's Black Cat/Felicia Hardy: 'Give her all the roles'

Inde Navarrette's performance in the 2025 horror film Obsession has propelled her into the spotlight, and a popular X post is now fueling calls for her to join the Marvel Cinematic Universe as Felicia Hardy, better known as Black Cat. The conversation, which quickly gained traction with hundreds of thousands of views, reflects the enthusiasm surrounding her recent success and the persistent desire among fans to see the character appear in live-action MCU projects.


This fan casting moment comes at a time when Navarrette's profile is surging. The low-budget horror hit, which exceeded expectations at the box office, has drawn praise for her central role, positioning her as a talent capable of blending vulnerability with intensity. For audiences invested in the MCU's evolving Spider-Man corner, such suggestions tap into broader excitement about potential new additions.

On June 13, 2026, a X user responded to another post from @Culture3ase that featured images and the statement: "Fans wants Inde Navarrette to join the MCU and play as Felicia Hardy (Black Cat)." The reply captured the trend succinctly: "You know a woman is gaining popularity when they start fan-casting the person as Black Cat LMFAOOO."

The main post accumulated over 44,000 likes, nearly 1,500 reposts, and more than 841,000 views in a short time. It included a follow-up noting the recurring nature of such fancasts: "“Fans want ____ to join the MCU as black cat” we know cause you guys fan cast everyone as black cat once they become famous HEHEHE."


Replies revealed a mix of support and familiar fandom patterns. One user highlighted her acting credentials and personal interest-

"Fuxk it she a Spider-Man and Tom Holland fan why not and can actually act."

“She does have some Felicia hardy vibes with her someone turn her hair white for scientific purposes” - said another user’

Another comment stated-

“Give her all the roles”

“To be fair… She’d be great” - wrote another user

Others focused on her visual fit, suggesting "someone turn her hair white for scientific purposes" to evoke Felicia's signature look.

Positive takes emphasised her range, with comments like "At least this time they chose someone who can actually act. Unlike the last time" and "She does have some Felicia hardy vibes."

Felicia Hardy, operating as the anti-heroine Black Cat, is a longstanding figure in Marvel Comics. Introduced as a master thief with a complicated romantic entanglement with Spider-Man, she brings moral ambiguity, agility, and flirtatious charm to stories. Her dual identity as a socialite and costumed cat burglar adds layers of intrigue and high-stakes action.

The MCU has yet to feature her in live-action, though fan interest remains high amid ongoing Spider-Man developments. Speculation often links her to upcoming projects involving Tom Holland's Peter Parker, where a new love interest or ally could fit narrative shifts. Her appearance in related animated content, such as Disney+ specials, has only heightened calls for a proper integration.


Black Cat's appeal lies in her complexity. Unlike straightforward heroes, she navigates grey areas, offering opportunities for dynamic storytelling that balances romance, crime, and superheroics. Fans see her as a natural fit for the MCU's street-level expansion.

Born on 3 March 2001 in Tucson, Arizona, Navarrette began gaining notice with roles in 13 Reasons Why and, more prominently, as Sarah Cushing (later Cortez) in Superman & Lois on The CW. She appeared in 47 episodes, establishing herself in the superhero genre before departing in the final season amid budget adjustments.

Her true breakout arrived with Obsession, directed by Curry Barker. Released in May 2026 after premiering at the Toronto International Film Festival, the film follows Bear (Michael Johnston), who uses a supernatural toy to make his crush Nikki (Navarrette) fall in love with him, unleashing horrific consequences. Navarrette's portrayal of Nikki, both as victim and vessel for sinister forces- earned widespread acclaim.


Critics and audiences praised her performance for its emotional depth and intensity. The film achieved strong box office results, reportedly grossing over $230 million on a modest budget, and holds high Rotten Tomatoes scores. Navarrette has spoken about humanising Nikki, balancing the character's tortured outbursts with relatability. This success has boosted her visibility significantly, with her Instagram following growing rapidly.

Supporters argue that Navarrette's screen presence aligns well with Felicia Hardy's characteristics. Her work in Obsession demonstrated the ability to convey charm, intensity, and vulnerability- qualities essential for a character who mixes seduction, cunning, and action. The stillness and sudden shifts she brought to Nikki suggest she could handle Black Cat's flirtatious yet dangerous energy.

Fans point to her "sultry vibe" and mannerisms as matching the character's comic-book persona. Comments highlight her acting range, distinguishing this fancast from others driven purely by popularity. Her prior experience in Superman & Lois also shows comfort with genre material involving physicality and emotional stakes.


That said, some responses urge caution, suggesting she pursue diverse non-franchise roles first to stretch her abilities further. Others see potential in her for various characters, from Zatanna to Wolverine variants, reflecting her versatility.

This fan casting fits a larger pattern in which horror or genre breakouts feed into superhero conversations. Performances that showcase charisma and depth, like Navarrette's, often spark MCU speculation. The timing, shortly after Obsession's theatrical run, demonstrates how quickly momentum translates into online discourse.

While no official casting has been confirmed, public enthusiasm helps gauge interest in characters like Black Cat. Audiences can look forward to Navarrette’s next steps, including any connections to Barker's upcoming supernatural project Anything but Ghosts.

Obsession continues its theatrical and on-demand run via Focus Features.